|Conundrums solved||3 (+1 tiebreak)|
He first appeared on 17 September 2019 against Matt Sykes, winning with 100 points. He then won his second heat game on a tiebreak conundrum. Following this, he put in six more wins, including two more centuries, and obtained 750 points to become the fifth octochamp of the series, eventually ranking 5th.
He took on 4th seed Morgan Sauer in the last quarterfinal of the series. Both players fought nip and tuck throughout; after the second commercial break, Evans converted a 13-point deficit into a 9-point lead between rounds 12 and 14 by taking successful gambles on MOLASSED and APORIAS, followed by managing 1 away on the last difficult one-large numbers round while Sauer only managed 7 away. Unfortunately for Evans, Sauer unravelled the crucial conundrum THEFRIDGE in 15 seconds to end Evans's unbeaten run and win by one point. Evans garnered an overall total of 827 points in his run.
While waiting for his finals appearance to be screened after his heats were shown, Evans made twelve appearances on ITV's Cash Trapped, which were filmed approximately a year before airing, one of which was sampled for an edition of It'll Be Alright On The Night.
|#||Date||Type||Contestant 1||Score||Contestant 2||Guest||Lex||Max|
|7163||17/09/2019||P||Matt Sykes||65 – 100||Andy Evans||Len Goodman||Susie Dent||127|
|7164||18/09/2019||P||Andy Evans||83* – 73||Gerry Gray||Len Goodman||Susie Dent||145|
|7165||19/09/2019||P||Andy Evans||94 – 53||Steve Taylor||Nina Hossain||Susie Dent||133|
|7166||20/09/2019||P||Andy Evans||114 – 61||Bekki Peckett||Nina Hossain||Susie Dent||125|
|7167||23/09/2019||P||Andy Evans||80 – 58||Abbie Arrowsmith||Nina Hossain||Susie Dent||118|
|7168||24/09/2019||P||Andy Evans||88 – 68||Daniel Smith||Nina Hossain||Susie Dent||126|
|7169||25/09/2019||P||Andy Evans||112 – 50||David Lee||Nina Hossain||Susie Dent||123|
|7170||26/09/2019||P||Andy Evans||89 – 74||Geoff Pinney||Pam Ayres||Susie Dent||137|
|7228||17/12/2019||QF||Morgan Sauer||78 – 77||Andy Evans||Jon Culshaw||Susie Dent||123|